Mar**** Manson vs My Chemical Romance

[OMGThePeSt]

So, because the years have gone by so fast, I kind of forget that times change. Kind of forget how old I really am getting, kind of forget how old by siblings are getting, well, earlier me and my little sister got into an argument.

My sister is like 14 and a huge My Chemical Romance fan, I on the other hand can't stand my Chemical romance. It's like burnt into my head that shes still a little girl, but then we started arguing about music.

And she pops off with "YOU LIKE MAR**** MANSON!" so i'm like, What does that have to do with how gay MCR is? And then shes like "Manson burns bibles! And gerardgay talks about the bible and god"

Ok, so not the best argument, but, because shes only 14, I just stopped, because i'm not goign to hurt her feelings.

Anyways, was just wondering how everyone felt about the two bands? My friends also have mixed re-actions. Tabloids have talked about a little fued between Manson and Gerard, and I personally think My Chem gets alot of influence for songs/makeup design from Manson......

So who do ye think is better?

[SuperSkunk]

My Chemical Romance is an annoyance on the music world and should be annihilated.

Mar**** Manson is alright at times. I love that song "King Kill 33" I think thats it. Either way he has a few good songs.

My chemical romance however has no good songs.

I used to have a girlfriend that was oppsessed with mcr and I had to go to a fucking concert with her. Worst concert ever. I just binge drinked and chain smoked my way through that concert trying to fry the memory of being there out of my head.

It was bad there were so many emos and I just wanted to hurt them all. Eventually I passed out puking my ass off in the back of my car and she enjoyed the rest of the concert by her self hahah.

[superflysuperwhite]

yeah there's really no comparison.

Manson, good

MCR, trash

[retarded007]

Mar**** Manson is good and MCR is gay

[SuperSkunk]

I think this is the first time everyone has agreed in one thread. Of course I may be speaking too soon because some emo kid will show up. So I don't know just felt like pointing that out.

[Kasnia]

This isn't even a competition. Manson wins, hands down.

[aardvarked]

agreed- manson is a god

i despise my chemical romance

[Palm3R]

You guys, don't make fun of MCR, it's not just music, it's a way of life!! :'(

nah. I've liked very few by MCR, none of their newer music though, but a couple of the older ones... still not something I listen to very often at all. I agree, they are kind of annoying though.

Manson is alright, I used to listen to a lot of his stuff. now I'm not so in-touch with any of his newer music though. but it's not like I have a problem with any of his music.

[Kasnia]

You guys, don't make fun of MCR, it's not just music, it's a way of life!! :'(

nah. I've liked very few by MCR, none of their newer music though, but a couple of the older ones... still not something I listen to very often at all. I agree, they are kind of annoying though.

Manson is alright, I used to listen to a lot of his stuff. now I'm not so in-touch with any of his newer music though. but it's not like I have a problem with any of his music.

I didn't know that MCR was still making music, honestly. O_o

[CHEETZzz]

lol MCR is for the gay little kids who are afraid of awesomeness.
they like to feel like they're rebelling when they're just eating what the mainstream feeds them.. dumbshits...

i personally am not really into Manson though i appreciate him... i know like 2 songs..
I wouldn't mind his music, and i read an article in Spin about him this one time and he's a pretty fuckin cool guy :D

[aardvarked]

Which two songs btw?

[magicninja]

mcr blows ass.

[aardvarked]

yup, weve got that

[filthylucre]

MCR? total shit. and its sad to watch so many kids jump on to the humongous bandwagon made up of emos, mainstream junkies, and those who think MCR is not mainstream and that their somehow being rebelious. the band has never had a song that ive enjoyed. and gerard way is just annoying as fuck

MANSON? not a fan but i respect what he's done. and on rare occasion i'll listen to a song or two

[Phoenix Fire]

why is this in hard rock/ metal

[Phoenix Fire]

People get shit wrong. Like FUCKING GREENDAY PLAYING ON MY PEARL JAM PANDORA STATION
imma break sumthing

[AlbertWesker]

Both are gay but Manson did make some good music for the Resident Evil soundtrack.

[Palm3R]

People get shit wrong. Like FUCKING GREENDAY PLAYING ON MY PEARL JAM PANDORA STATION
imma break sumthing

ahhhahahaha! that fucking sucks. I had to laugh though. how do you get Greenday from Pearl Jam!? XD

[claymore]

my chemical romance is for whiny emo bitchs and posers
i have yet to meet somone that likes mcr and isnt one of those

[badussy]

Yep manson definetly wins

[Phoenix Fire]

You cant compare mcr with Manson.
Thats like comparing an anal fissure to God himself.

[undeadpaladin]

oi FUCK YOU ALL Mar**** Manson is fucking amazing but mcr isnt bad there are a few good songs most are anoying as shit but hey just like everyone else they got lucky a few times so you have to give them some credit.

[MissNymph]

In my opinion,
Manson fucking rocks.
MCR is mainstream watered-down poprockcrap.
=]

[Raditude]

Nothing personal against MCR, if they are religious, but they are emo, (why is this under hard rock/metal) and Gerard's voice is annoying.

As for Mar**** Manson, I heard he claims MCR is a ripoff of him. Manson seems like a ripoff of another famous musician, oh what's his name... Alice Cooper? I like some of Manson's music, but don't like the things I hear about him.

[Mpuckett93]

Manson ripped off his image but not his music. Coopers music sucked dick. He was supposed to be the bad guy of early Metal. What was his meanest song? Schools out? Wtf, wow schools out, go fuck yourself Cooper. But back on topic now, Manson would cut out the intestines of MCR and hang their bodies from a tree on a hill. Then shit out an album that's better than anything MCR's ever made.

[MissNymph]

Manson ripped off his image but not his music. Coopers music sucked dick. He was supposed to be the bad guy of early Metal. What was his meanest song? Schools out? Wtf, wow schools out, go fuck yourself Cooper. But back on topic now, Manson would cut out the intestines of MCR and hang their bodies from a tree on a hill. Then shit out an album that's better than anything MCR's ever made.

HAHAHAHA.
I completely agree with you about Manson & MCR.
;)

[Keeglef2]

I listen to both bands. Two different genres. Have nothing to do with eachother. If you dont like pop punk, fine. If you dont like alternative metal, fine.

It's trivial. let people listen to what they want to.

[Keeglef2]

Nothing personal against MCR, if they are religious, but they are emo, (why is this under hard rock/metal) and Gerard's voice is annoying.

As for Mar**** Manson, I heard he claims MCR is a ripoff of him. Manson seems like a ripoff of another famous musician, oh what's his name... Alice Cooper? I like some of Manson's music, but don't like the things I hear about him.


my chemical romance isnt emo. People say that all the time, but its incorrect. Emo is rites of spring, embrace, heroin, and other eighties and early nineties emotive hardcore groups..
This modern stuff isnt emo. Its usually pop punk or post hardcore.

[maggotcutie]

no question that manson wins

[anarchists digester]

MCR is a disgusting excuse for music and should never have been allowed to make that shit, Manson blows my mind with his rage/depressing songs he always has a song for my mood.
He is a god and shouldn't be compared against MCR!!

[Pirate9687]

Manson=Badass

My Chemical Romance=A bunch of buttfucking pussies.

[Pirate9687]

...and there is nothing wrong with burning bibles by the way.

[lazy_D]

manson no doubt.....


"i wish my lawn was emo so it'd cut itself"

[Wolkkkk]

My chemical romance is so lame that it would hurt my balls just to be on the same continent with those guys. Kids stuff is for kids

[hellknight]

mar**** manson has an awesome voice and some of his songs have a deep meaning about this fucking world.i used to be obssesed with him.but his whole image,IMO i believe it's bad...ok so he might not care about what others say and be like this to cause anger but some of these are extreme and become annoying.about MCR...they are retarded mainstream assholes who write so-called emotional songs for emo kiddies (not that i hate emos but they kinda annoy me).lol they even claimed that "emo is shit and we aren't emo) yeah right...that's why you have a whiny voice and write this emotional songs?'nuff said

[Wolkkkk]

Also Mansinthe is delicious

[hellknight]

Also Mansinthe is delicious

really?i've read really bad reviews about that.is it with opium or the usual 70%vol.?

[Wolkkkk]

really?i've read really bad reviews about that.is it with opium or the usual 70%vol.?

66.6% alcohol

It was ok. To tell the truth there are better ones out there.
Bairnsfather Bitter for example.
Or the stronger ones.

Mansinthe didn`t really bring the effect i was looking, but tasty anyway =)

[hellknight]

66.6% alcohol

coincidence? XD

[N3VVRmiNd]

They're both stupid. MCR makes good covers just like Mar**** Manson, but MCR is too faggish and commercial, and Manson is *****g to me.

[alucard621]

nice necro post.

but, i can't help but think that the people that don't like manson are the ones who've never taken the time to really listen to his works (and not just the shit on the radio) or are the ones who don't understand him.

as for mcr? i thought their second album was decent, i'm not going to lie. or, at least i did in 8th grade. but their newest? garbage. what i dont get is that their newest album is the one to make them popular, as well.

[codyclarke]

they both suck.
and when i heard Manson's cover of pink floyd's "another brick in the wall" i wanted to fucking smash the radio. he RUINED it..

[DBMRufus]

Marylin Manson is alright. MCR is a bullshit emo-prep punk-turned-rock-fad cultband for 14 year old boys and fat and/or ugly high school girls .

The choice should be pretty clear by now.